
Susan Talarico is what happens when you combine a luxury real estate broker, a competitive athlete, a ski instructor, a pair of rescue terriers, and just enough caffeine-fueled sarcasm to survive Scottsdale real estate for 25+ years. Originally from Buffalo, NY, because apparently lake-effect snow and emotional endurance were part of the training program, she relocated to Arizona in 1999 and immediately decided the desert needed more personality, better marketing, and significantly fewer boring property descriptions.
Long before real estate, Susan spent her younger years dominating competitive roller skating. She became a National Champion herself, then moved into coaching, where she trained two National Champions and volunteered as a Special Olympics coach. Calm hobbies were never really an option. Not content to risk injury on wheels alone, she also became a competitive water skier and former New York State Women's Jump Champion, before escalating things into a Senior World Championship in swivel skiing, which sounds fake until you realize she willingly straps herself to skis and spins in circles behind a boat for sport.
Professionally, Susan has built a career around high-end homes, lifestyle properties, ski lake communities, land sales, and telling people what they actually need to hear instead of what every other agent copy-pastes into MLS remarks. Equal parts trusted advisor and professional chaos coordinator, she blends sharp negotiation skills with the energy of someone who may or may not own three different jackets for three different types of water conditions. Former brokerage owner, longtime REALTOR®, adoption advocate, dog fanatic, and accidental athlete whose hobbies consistently spiral into championships.

At home, Susan is outnumbered by men, dogs, motorsports equipment, and opinions. She is the mother of twin sons addicted to motocross, the wife of a car enthusiast who probably thinks another project vehicle is a reasonable decision, and the personal assistant to Maggie and Homer, two rescue dogs who contribute absolutely nothing financially but run the household emotionally. She believes real estate is a conversation, marketing should never sound corporate, and life is too short for weak margaritas, cheap wine, bad staging, or people who hit Reply All unnecessarily. Ask her about Jack Russell Terriers, waterski lakes, roller skating, snow skiing, or Arizona real estate, and prepare to lose the next two hours of your life.
The Lake Effect
Susan has called McDowell Mountain Ranch home since 1999, while spending most weekends at her secondary residence in Lakeside Ski Village. This balance between desert living and ski-lake life gives her an authentic, first-hand understanding of how lifestyle, recreation, and seasonality intersect. Clients benefit from insight shaped by experience, not assumption.
My top 5
favorite things
Water Skiing
Susan is an avid water skier who spends meaningful time at her home away from home within one of Arizona’s ski-lake communities. A national competitor in swivel skiing, National Show Ski Association Board Member, and certified Show Ski Judge, her connection to the sport runs deep. The lake is where she resets, connects, and embraces a lifestyle rooted in movement, joy, and tradition , and around the holidays, you might even catch her in costume, gliding by on the water.
Learn More
Snow Skiing
A lifelong lover of outdoor recreation, Susan seamlessly trades water skis for snow skis when winter arrives. A certified snow ski instructor with the Professional Ski Instructors of America and more than 30 years on the slopes, skiing remains a constant. Whether carving fresh powder or enjoying a quiet day on the mountain, the sport mirrors her approach to real estate with focus, balance, momentum, and confidence earned over time.
Learn More
Setting Records
Susan loves bringing people together in unforgettable ways, especially when it involves water, teamwork, and audacity. She has participated in the Guinness World Record three times, each setting a new mark for the world’s largest synchronized waterski ballet line. For Susan, it was never just about the record, but the shared experience, precision, and collective energy behind achieving something truly extraordinary.
Learn More.jpg)
It's a Dog's Life
Susan’s two rescue dogs, Maggie and Homer, are beloved members of the family. Maggie, a Jack Russell Terrier, and Homer, a JackWeenie, are constant companions, from lake house trips to hikes and paddleboard yoga. Equal parts adventure buddies and comic relief, they bring levity and loyalty to everyday moments, reminding Susan that life is best enjoyed with curiosity, movement, and mischief.
Learn More
Family
At the heart of everything Susan values is time spent with family. Whether it’s a road trip, a lake weekend, or a simple moment together, she treasures experiences that create lasting memories. These moments ground her, inspire her, and reinforce what matters most, connection, shared laughter, and building a life that feels as good as it looks.
Learn More.jpg)